Group settings hurt expressions of intelligence, especially in women

March, 2012

Comparing performance on an IQ test when it is given under normal conditions and when it is given in a group situation reveals that IQ drops in a group setting, and for some (mostly women) it drops dramatically.

This is another demonstration of stereotype threat, which is also a nice demonstration of the contextual nature of intelligence. The study involved 70 volunteers (average age 25; range 18-49), who were put in groups of 5. Participants were given a baseline IQ test, on which they were given no feedback. The group then participated in a group IQ test, in which 92 multi-choice questions were presented on a monitor (both individual and group tests were taken from Cattell’s culture fair intelligence test). Each question appeared to each person at the same time, for a pre-determined time. After each question, they were provided with feedback in the form of their own relative rank within the group, and the rank of one other group member. Ranking was based on performance on the last 10 questions. Two of each group had their brain activity monitored.

Here’s the remarkable thing. If you gather together individuals on the basis of similar baseline IQ, then you can watch their IQ diverge over the course of the group IQ task, with some dropping dramatically (e.g., 17 points from a mean IQ of 126). Moreover, even those little affected still dropped some (8 points from a mean IQ of 126).

Data from the 27 brain scans (one had to be omitted for technical reasons) suggest that everyone was initially hindered by the group setting, but ‘high performers’ (those who ended up scoring above the median) managed to largely recover, while ‘low performers’ (those who ended up scoring below the median) never did.

Personality tests carried out after the group task found no significant personality differences between high and low performers, but gender was a significant variable: 10/13 high performers were male, while 11/14 low performers were female (remember, there was no difference in baseline IQ — this is not a case of men being smarter!).

There were significant differences between the high and low performers in activity in the amygdala and the right lateral prefrontal cortex. Specifically, all participants had an initial increase in amygdala activation and diminished activity in the prefrontal cortex, but by the end of the task, the high-performing group showed decreased amygdala activation and increased prefrontal cortex activation, while the low performers didn’t change. This may reflect the high performers’ greater ability to reduce their anxiety. Activity in the nucleus accumbens was similar in both groups, and consistent with the idea that the students had expectations about the relative ranking they were about to receive.

It should be pointed out that the specific feedback given — the relative ranking — was not a factor. What’s important is that it was being given at all, and the high performers were those who became less anxious as time went on, regardless of their specific ranking.

There are three big lessons here. One is that social pressure significantly depresses talent (meetings make you stupid?), and this seems to be worse when individuals perceive themselves to have a lower social rank. The second is that our ability to regulate our emotions is important, and something we should put more energy into. And the third is that we’ve got to shake ourselves loose from the idea that IQ is something we can measure in isolation. Social context matters.

Recent posts at Mynd

global prevalence of multiple sclerosis

Cognitive decline is common in those with multiple sclerosis, but not everyone is so afflicted. What governs whether an individual will suffer...

A study involving 124 teenagers has found that those who were most accurate at tapping along with a metronome also showed the most consistent...

stock image

A large study, involving 3,690 older adults, has found that drugs with strong anticholinergic effects cause memory and cognitive impairment when...

St Anselm graduation

A very large genetic study has revealed that genetic differences have little effect on educational achievement. The study involved more than 125,...

Bright light therapy lamp

A small study involving 18 individuals with at least one mild traumatic brain injury with related sleep disturbance has shown that six weeks of...

Premature infant with ventilator

More than 10% of all babies are born preterm every year, and prematurity is a well-established risk factor for cognitive impairment at some level...

CPAP apparatus on mannequin

A new study adds to growing evidence of a link between sleep problems and Alzheimer’s. The interesting thing is that this association...

A false bus stop outside a nursing home, for the benefit of dementia patients

Family caregivers of dementia sufferers who are reluctant to use adult day care services might like to note the findings of a telephone survey....

Last year, a cancer drug, Bexarotene, was touted as a potential treatment for Alzheimer’s disease. However, four independent studies have...

Cinnamon sticks

I’ve been happily generous with cinnamon on my breakfast ever since the first hints came out that cinnamon might help protect against...

autistic toddler stacking cans

A recent report from Autistica estimates that nearly a quarter (24%) of children with autism are non-verbal or minimally verbal — problems...

screenshot semantic space

A recent study reveals that when we focus on searching for something, regions across the brain are pulled into the search. The study sheds light...

meditating on a flame

Three classroom experiments have found that students who meditated before a psychology lecture scored better on a quiz that followed than...

image from study

We talk about memory for ‘events’, but how does the brain decide what an event is? How does it decide what is part of an...

dilated eye

Why do we find it so hard to stay on task for long? A recent study uses a new technique to show how the task control network and the default...

action replay box

We know sleep helps consolidate memories. Now a new study sheds light on how your sleeping brain decides what’s worth keeping. The study...